![fire truck]()
On the heels of five dispatchers being laid off a week ago, the union representing Moose Jaw Firefighters is ringing warning bells.
President of the Moose Jaw Professional Firefighters Association Gord Hewitt sees the loss of the dispatcher positions as a sign of things to come and has released this statement to Moose Jaw residents, on the association's behalf.
~~~~~~~~~~~
What does your fire service cost in Moose Jaw?
At a cost of just 47 cents a day to the average household, Moose Jaw has one of the most affordable full-time fire departments in Canada.
Despite this fact, the city of Moose Jaw continues to allow frontline fire department resources to dwindle, which will inevitably have a negative impact on public and firefighter safety, while saving taxpayers pennies, if anything.
The Moose Jaw Firefighters Association can stay silent about these cuts no longer. We believe you and your family have a right to know how city decisions about fire department resources might affect your family’s safety.
As many people may be aware, on Friday July 17th all Moose Jaw Fire Dispatchers were relieved of their duties. Dispatching for the Moose Jaw Fire Department is being moved to a Provincial call center in Prince Albert. This results in the loss of four full-time and one part time dispatcher, five good jobs in our community and people who lived and worked in our city of Moose Jaw. They were five people who understood the uniqueness of our neighbourhoods and rural areas. This is essential as a point of contact for the public when they have an emergency.
We were also informed that our Mechanic position will remain vacant, permanently. Unfortunately our Mechanic, Garth Rogers, passed away in April. This position was included in the budget for 2015. Garth performed continuous preventative maintenance, so our equipment was ready to use when we and the public needed it most. This equipment is specialized, unique to our department and vital to the safety of our firefighters and the residents of Moose Jaw. Firefighters have continued to perform minor maintenance on equipment however; much of the work requires a mechanic trained to work with this specialized equipment. In addition, the mechanic is responsible for much of the building maintenance, performing double duty.
Additionally, in 2004 we had a Fire Inspector position and Training Officer position deleted.
The department is currently short staffed 2 Firefighter positions. They are currently being backfilled by overtime rather than the significantly cheaper option of hiring 2 junior firefighters. This leads to the speculation the next cut will be to our fire suppression division. This would reduce the number of firefighters that will respond to your emergency.
Last year the decision was made to no longer support the requirement of Firefighters to maintain an EMT or Primary Care Paramedic license. We had approximately 30 firefighters trained to this level that have now been reduced to First Responder status. The Fire department operates within a 2 tiered medical response system. We respond in conjunction with EMS to life threatening medical emergencies. Often, there is the possibility that we will arrive prior to EMS to initiate patient care. We also respond to several types of incidents where only fire has access to patients.
Having Firefighters trained to the Primary Care Paramedic level is a value added to the Moose Jaw Fire Department and to the residents of Moose Jaw. It changes nothing when it comes to firefighter wages, it’s just simply better for the community and more responsibility for the firefighters. Our Association supports a department that is well trained, operationally effective and trained to the highest standard. We want to be equipped to provide optimum service to the residents of Moose Jaw.
These changes are all a symptom of a bigger problem, the continued marginalization of the Fire Service in Moose Jaw.
Our current staffing level has been in place since 2000 when we entered into contract with 15 Wing to provide structural fire protection. At that time we had a minimum of eight firefighters on duty, four at each hall. 15 Wing took into consideration the minimum safety standards required for firefighters to perform basic emergency functions of our job and made it a requirement that initial response would be five firefighters from South Hill supplemented by additional firefighters from North Hill fire hall. The proposal to 15 Wing was that the department would hire eight additional firefighters and a deputy chief. We would have a minimum of five firefighters responding from each hall. This is an excellent benefit to the City of Moose Jaw. It is our understanding that in 2015, the City will receive $1.18 million dollars for this service.
In 1999, the City concluded its second independent fire hall review. Both studies showed the minimum number of firefighters that should be on duty at one time in the City of Moose Jaw should be 10. These studies were done by experts that evaluated the specific needs of our City. Since this time, research was done by the “National Fire Protection Association” (NFPA) and other institutes, to determine appropriate staffing levels for fire departments.
The result was the NFPA 1710 standard. NFPA 1710 tells us that in order for a fire department to operate safely at a two-story residential fire, there should be 15 to 17 firefighters on scene within 8 minutes. We have 10 to 12. Additional studies have now been completed by the National Institute for Science and Technology that reiterate the importance of staffing levels.
Over the past 2 years residents have been asked to participate in surveys related to City services. The first survey found Fire to be the top-rated service. It also found that citizens valued fire protection second only to ensuring quality in the water supply.
The second survey was the Citizens Budget Survey. Again citizens showed the value they put in the fire service by voting for an increase to the budget. Not a decrease. The third survey was the Cast Iron Replacement survey. Option 5 was to cut the operating budget and transfer funds to water main replacement. This would require 10% reduction in existing services. Again, the results showed an overwhelming majority did not want cuts to services.
So why is the City continuing to cut resources and staff from the Moose Jaw Fire Service despite the public’s feedback? Resident’s tax dollars were spent to perform these surveys and now the results are being ignored. This should be of utmost concern for the people of Moose Jaw.
Perhaps the reason many citizens are supportive of their fire service is because they realize the value they receive for their tax dollars. According to City documents the average residential household paid $170 per year in taxes for their fire service. That’s 47 cents per day for the average household. Each member of this department (that already operates well below the National Standard for safe firefighting operations) costs taxpayers a fraction of a penny per day.
Further reducing fire department resources and moving further away from recognized public safety standards would save each household pennies a day, if anything. By the same token, improving fire department resources can be done for pennies a day to the average household or with little or no impact at all if phased in over time or if City budget dollars are reprioritized.
For just 47 cents a day, based on the average taxable property assessment, each Moose Jaw household gets full-time fire protection 24/7/365, from a minimum of 10 firefighters on duty who are ready to respond to virtually any emergency in minutes. This includes fire suppression and rescue, vehicle extrication, medical emergencies, high/low angle rescue, confined space rescue, ice/water rescue, hazardous materials response and more including Dispatchers who live, work in and know our neighbourhoods. We have an inspection branch staffed by one Fire Inspector.
Fire protection is an investment in our community. An adequately-resourced fire department offering fast and effective emergency response saves lives, reduces property loss, reduces the economic impact of commercial and industrial fires and generally lowers commercial and residential insurance rates.
Protecting the citizens of Moose Jaw and their property should be the City's number one priority. Residents of Moose Jaw expect their tax dollars to keep them and their families safe.
The Moose Jaw Professional Firefighters Association is willing and ready to work cooperatively with the City in any initiatives that will help improve our ability to safely and effectively protect the citizens of this great city.
We are concerned that communication has broken down, and don't believe optimal effectiveness can be achieved without improving that. This was evident during the recent layoffs and the elimination of our Dispatch.
Despite all the facts and feedback from the public and the two fire hall reviews, our service continues to face cuts.
We have tried to be respectful and conduct ourselves professionally through this time. We are tired of looking over our shoulders continuously wondering when the next cut is going to be. Enough is enough!
The Moose Jaw Professional Firefighters Association